Academic Honesty, Plagiarism and the use of Generative Artificial Intelligence

Academic honesty is expected of all students as it is essential to the work of the college. Given this, academic dishonesty is taken very seriously; it may be especially tempting—and harmful—in writing. Plagiarism (including the use of generative artificial intelligence), falsification of documents, and other cases of academic fraud carry a range of penalties, up to and including expulsion, and may be disclosed in the student’s academic record. It is a sad fact that in recent years students have been suspended and expelled for plagiarism, including the use of generative artificial intelligence.

Plagiarism is the failure to give appropriate acknowledgment when drawing on others’ written works. Including passages that have been composed by or with the assistance of generative artificial intelligence programs is plagiarism, whether or not the “original” text is preserved in any other document or other location. Plagiarism does not refer merely to submitting the written work of another in its entirety. It could include adopting only parts of sentences directly without acknowledging the source or taking ideas or the structure of an argument without doing so, even when no phrases or sentences are incorporated directly. Students should be particularly careful not to use material found on the internet without citing the source properly, regardless of how slight the appropriations. Students should not include passages that have been composed, translated, or substantially revised by computer programs, e.g. by generative artificial intelligence platforms or comparable tools. The college encourages students to use papers to raise their own questions, expand upon them, pursue plausible answers, and develop a persuasive argument; reference to, or use of, secondary sources is not required typically and is inappropriate generally. Students who struggle with writing are encouraged to draw on the wealth of help available to them, including reaching out to tutors, writing assistants, friends and fellow students. Students who are found guilty of plagiarism—which includes the use of generative artificial intelligence—may face a range of penalties, up to and including expulsion.

With the founding of the New Program, St. John’s distinguished itself by not doing what most other colleges do (no majors, no textbooks, an all-required, shared curriculum). We can now add to that list not allowing artificially generated text for anything in our academic program. St. John’s remains committed to being a community where people support one another in the human activity of searching for truth. Writing at the college is one vital means of doing so. Recently, a group of students, tutors and staff gathered to articulate the importance of writing at the college; their inspiring and sometimes provocative words can be found in this Statement on Writing at St. John’s College.

Procedures for Accusations of Academic Dishonesty When AI Use is Suspected

Student work that is produced in conjunction with the use of AI will not be credited to the student. In connection with a St. John’s College essay or class assignment, use of AI for planning, outlining, translating, composing, paraphrasing, or revising, is considered a failure to complete the assignment. The only exception to this is if a tutor gave advance written permission and the student provided a full citation in the assignment. If a tutor would like there to be a different consequence for AI usage (such as failure of the class), that tutor must have consulted the Dean or Associate Dean before the assignment was communicated to the class. The different consequence must apply to all members of the class.

Before concluding that a student has used AI in violation of this policy, the tutor will raise the concern with the student and give the student an opportunity to respond, including an opportunity to describe how the student completed the assignment and to provide drafts or other materials. If the student confesses to the tutor, the student will meet with the Assistant Dean to review the academic honesty policy, and a letter will be sent to the student as a record of the process and to underline that a subsequent offence may lead to suspension or expulsion; the Assistant Dean also keeps a record of all students who are guilty of academic dishonesty. If the student disputes the tutor’s concern that AI was used, the student will meet with the Assistant Dean and will have an opportunity to describe how the student completed the assignment and to provide drafts or other materials. The Assistant Dean will review the evidence provided by the tutor and student and decide whether AI was used. If the student is found guilty, a letter will be sent to the student, as also applies to a student who confessed; if the student is found not guilty, there will be no letter and no record kept of the accusation. Where an AI detection tool has been used, its result will not be the sole basis for a finding. The student will be told which tool was used and what it reported, and will be given an opportunity to respond.

Whenever failure of an essay could entail or contribute to failure of the class, the tutor will notify the Assistant Dean. If suspension or expulsion due to violation of academic honesty is a possible outcome, the Assistant Dean will refer the case to a review committee made up of two tutors and one staff member, none of whom has had any prior involvement in the matter and each of whom confirms that he or she has no close relationship with the student.  The student and the tutor shall then each have the opportunity to present their view of the matter to the committee; the committee will decide the outcome of the case.  The Assistant Dean will present the matter to the committee, provide it with the record of the investigation and answer its questions, and will then withdraw without deliberating or voting. The committee will issue a short written decision stating its findings, the outcome, and the reasons for it.  However a decision is reached, the student may appeal the decision to the Dean of the student’s campus, in writing, within ten days of being notified of it. An appeal may be taken on the ground of procedural error, evidence that was not available earlier, or an outcome disproportionate to the finding. Before an appeal is taken, the Dean will not have directed the investigation, expressed a view on the student’s use of AI, or approved the outcome. Where the Dean has been substantively involved, the appeal will be decided by the Dean of the other campus or another designee identified in advance.

Prohibited use of AI by a student may lead to suspension or expulsion, if instances of dishonesty are repeated, and will be referred to the review committee. Dishonesty in an annual essay, preceptorial essay, or master’s essay will be handled through the review committee, and can result in suspension or expulsion even in a first instance.